These results can not be generalised
to the Australian population due to the fact that the sample size is skewed
in the above manner, the sample size is too small, and the respondents
were not able to be randomly picked, very few complete data sets (principals
and TL from same school) exist. However, it is likely the results are in
the general direction for the populations of urban K-6 schools in Australia.
FREQUENCY ANALYSIS DATA
38 Teacher Librarians responded
in Australia to the questionnaire.
FREQUENCY DATA was as follows:
Age:
51.4% of teacher librarians who
responded were between the ages of 40-49.
35.1% of teacher librarians who
responded were between the ages of 50-59.
8.1% of teacher librarians who responded
were between the ages of 20-29.
2.7% of teacher librarians who responded
were between the ages of 30-39.
2.7% of teacher librarians who responded
were 60+ years of age.
Gender:
100% of teacher librarians who responded
were female.
Type of School:
84.2% of respondents were from government
schools, the remaining 15.8% were from private schools.
Advertised Position:
73.7% of teacher librarians who
responded were appointed to an advertised position, the remaining 23.7%
were appointed to unadvertised positions, reasons were not given for appointment.
Internet Connection in Library
Resource Centre:
78.4% of TL’s who responded had
1 internet connection in the LRC.
10.8% of TL’s who responded had
2 internet connection in the LRC.
8.1% of TL’s who responded had 0
internet connection in the LRC.
2.7% of TL’s who responded had 6
internet connection in the LRC.
There is some concern on this question about whether or not research participants understood the question being asked, thus the accuracy of results is uncertain.
Internet Points in LRC:
70.3% of TL’s who responded had
1 internet point in the LRC.
10.8% of TL’s who responded had
0 internet point in the LRC.
10.8% of TL’s who responded had
3 internet point in the LRC.
2.7% of TL’s who responded had 10
internet point in the LRC.
5.4% of TL’s who responded had 20
internet point in the LRC.
The same concern exists with this question as with the internet connections in LRC question.
List Server:
48.6% of TL’s who responded did
not subscribe to a listserv for teacher librarians.
51.4% of TL’s who responded did
not subscribe to a listserv for teacher librarians.
Advanced Skills Teacher:
38.9% of TL’s who responded were
not an advanced skills teacher.
61.1% of TL’s who responded were
an advanced skills teacher.
Number of Years in Current Position:
50% of TL’s who responded have been
in current position for 0-4 years.
27.8% of TL’s who responded have
been in current position for 5-9 years.
11.1% of TL’s who responded have
been in current position for 10-14 years.
8.3% of TL’s who responded have
been in current position for 15-19 years.
Number of Years in Executive Position:
77.8% of TL’s who responded have
never been in an executive position.
13.9% of TL’s who responded have
spent between 0-4 years in an executive position.
2.8% of TL’s who responded have
spent between 5-9 years in an executive position.
2.8% of TL’s who responded have
spent between 15-19 years in an executive position.
2.8% of TL’s who responded have
spent between 20-24 years in an executive position.
Number of hours TL/s do/es in
the School:
57.9% filled 1 f/t position equalling
40hrs/week.
10.5% did between 10-19 hours/week.
5.3% did between 0-9hours/week.
10.6% did between 20-29hours/week.
5.3% did between 30-39hours/week.
5.3% did between 80-89hours/week.
2 f/t positions
5.3% did between 120-129hours/week.
3 f/t positions
Professional Association Memberships
(Number of):
41.7% of TL’s who responded were
members of 2 Professional Associations.
19.4% of TL’s who responded were
members of 3 Professional Associations.
16.6% of TL’s who responded were
members of 1 Professional Associations.
8.3% of TL’s who responded were
members of 4 Professional Associations.
5.6% of TL’s who responded were
members of 5 Professional Associations.
5.6% of TL’s who responded were
members of 0 Professional Associations.
2.8% of TL’s who responded were
members of 6 Professional Associations.
Qualifications:
48.6% of TL’s who responded had
an academic qualification of a BA (Hons) or BA dip ed or equivalent.
40.5% of TL’s who responded had
a Bachelors degree or equivalent.
10.8% of TL’s who responded had
an MA degree or equivalent.
Number of Years Teaching Prior
to Appointment:
27% of TL’s who responded had spent
between 1-4 years teaching prior to appointment.
24.3% of TL’s who responded had
spent between 5-9 years teaching prior to appointment.
24.3% of TL’s who responded had
spent between 10-14 years teaching prior to appointment.
10.8% of TL’s who responded had
spent between 20+ years teaching prior to appointment.
8.1% of TL’s who responded had spent
between 0 years teaching prior to appointment.
5.4% of TL’s who responded had spent
between 15-19 years teaching prior to appointment.
Number of TL journals subscribed
to:
27.1% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 2 journals.
24.3% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 3 journals.
21.6% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 1 journals.
8.1% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 4 journals.
8.1% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 0 journals.
5.4% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 5 journals.
5.4% of the TL’s that responded
subscribe to 6 journals.
40 Principals responded in Australia
to the questionnaire
FREQUENCY DATA was as follows:
Age:
42.9% of Principals who responded
were between 40-49 years of age.
51.4% of Principals who responded
were between 50-59 years of age.
5.7% of Principals who responded
were between 30-39 years of age.
Gender:
57.1% of principals who responded
were male.
42.9% of principals who responded
were female.
Type of School:
82.9% of principals who responded
came from government schools, the remaining 17.1% came from private schools.
Number of Years in Current Position:
60% of principals who responded
have been in current position for 0-4 years.
25.7% of principals who responded
have been in current position for 5-9 years.
14.3% of principals who responded
have been in current position for 10-14 years.
Number of Years in Executive
Position:
31.4% of principals who responded
have been in executive positions for 10-14 years.
20% of principals who responded
have been in executive positions for 15-19 years.
17.1% of principals who responded
have been in executive positions for 5-9 years.
17.1% of principals who responded
have been in executive positions for 25+ years.
14.3% of principals who responded
have been in executive positions for 20-24 years.
Number of TL’s the Principal has
Worked with:
35.2% of principals who responded
have worked with 1-2 TL’s.
32.4% of principals who responded
have worked with 3-4 TL’s.
20.6% of principals who responded
have worked with 5-6 TL’s.
8.8% of principals who responded
have worked with 7-8 TL’s.
2.9% of principals who responded
have worked with more than 9 TL’s.
Professional Associations:
31.4% of principals who responded
were members of 2 Professional Associations.
31.4% of principals who responded
were members of 3 Professional Associations.
20% of principals who responded
were members of 1 Professional Associations.
8.6% of principals who responded
were members of 0 Professional Associations.
8.6% of principals who responded
were members of 4 Professional Associations.
Qualifications:
35.3% of principals who responded
had an Honours, Dip Ed degree or equivalent.
32.4% of principals who responded
had a MA degree.
29.4% of principals who responded
had a Bachelors Degree.
2.9% of principals who responded
had a PhD degree.
Number of Years Teaching Prior
to Appointment:
40% of principals who responded
have spend 15-19 years teaching prior to appointment.
40% of principals who responded
have spend 20+ years teaching prior to appointment.
11.4% of principals who responded
have spend 10-14 years teaching prior to appointment.
8.6% of principals who responded
have spend 5-9 years teaching prior to appointment.
FREQUENCY ANALYSIS of School-based Information
Internet Connections in the school:
100% of responding principals have
between 0-19 internet connections in their school.
Internet Points in the School:
75% of responding principals have
between 0-19 internet points in their school.
9.4% of responding principals have
between 20-39 internet points in their school.
6.3% of responding principals have
between 40-59 internet points in their school.
3.1% of responding principals have
between 60-79 internet points in their school.
3.1% of responding principals have
between 80-99 internet points in their school.
Number of Students in School:
40% of responding principals have
200-399 students in their school.
31.4% of responding principals have
400-599 students in their school.
14.3% of responding principals have
0-199 students in their school.
8.6% of responding principals have
1000+ students in their school.
2.9% of responding principals have
600-799 students in their school.
2.9% of responding principals have
800-999 students in their school.
Number of Teaching Staff in School:
53.1% of principals who responded
have 0-19 teaching staff.
31.3% of responding principals have
20-39 teaching staff.
6.3% of responding principals have
40-59 teaching staff.
6.3% of responding principals have
80-99 teaching staff.
3.1% of responding principals have
60-79 teaching staff.
Number of TLs on Staff:
70.6% of responding principals have
one full/time TL.
17.6% of responding principals have
less than one full/time TL.
8.8% of responding principals have
two full/time TLs on staff.
2.9% of responding principals have
three full/time TLs on staff.
Location of School:
88.6% of responding principals’
schools are located in urban areas.
11.4% of responding principals’
schools are located in rural areas.
Year Levels of School:
82.9% of responding principals’
schools were K-6.
8.6% of responding principals’ schools
were 7-10.
2.9% of responding principals’ schools
were 11-12.
5.7% of responding principals’ schools
were K-10.
DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS FROM FREQUENCY ANALYSIS
Descriptive Statistics from frequency
analysis for Teacher Librarians perception of time spent on tasks/ or in
support of tasks by the Principal
Question | Present | Present | Future | Future |
Mean | SD | Mean | SD | |
1 | 3.4121 | .722 | 3.789 | .741 |
2 | 3.184 | 1.010 | 3.737 | .760 |
3 | 3.632 | .786 | 3.711 | .927 |
4 | 3.395 | .755 | 3.632 | 1.125 |
5 | 3.263 | 1.005 | 3.737 | .921 |
6 | 3.263 | 1.267 | 3.632 | .970 |
7 | 2.921 | 1.343 | 3.263 | 1.349 |
8 | 3.237 | 1.076 | 3.342 | 1.381 |
9 | 2.368 | 1.303 | 3.316 | .873 |
10 | 2.789 | 1.166 | 3.526 | .893 |
11 | 3.184 | 1.205 | 3.737 | .724 |
12 | 2.132 | 1.436 | 3.289 | 1.183 |
13 | 3.395 | 1.054 | 3.763 | .751 |
14 | 2.395 | 1.242 | 3.237 | .998 |
15 | 3.342 | 1.021 | 3.658 | .966 |
16 | 2.421 | 1.328 | 3.158 | 1.220 |
17 | 3.158 | .886 | 3.421 | .976 |
18 | 2.632 | 1.025 | 3.026 | 1.026 |
19 | 2.816 | .926 | 3.053 | .985 |
20 | 2.421 | .919 | 2.816 | 1.062 |
21 | 2.789 | 1.298 | 3.316 | .933 |
22 | 2.789 | 1.044 | 3.211 | 1.044 |
23 | 2.579 | 1.368 | 3.026 | 1.241 |
24 | 3.079 | 1.239 | 3.553 | 1.005 |
25 | 3.211 | 1.119 | 3.526 | .979 |
26 | 2.553 | 1.032 | 2.895 | 1.203 |
27 | 2.974 | 1.052 | 3.395 | .855 |
28 | 2.947 | 1.161 | 3.395 | 1.054 |
29 | 2.658 | 1.279 | 2.947 | 1.161 |
30 | 2.132 | 1.580 | 3.132 | 1.095 |
31 | 1.632 | 1.422 | 2.737 | 1.178 |
Descriptive Statistics from frequency
analysis for Principals perception of time spent on tasks/ or in support
of tasks by themselves
Question | Present | Present | Future | Future |
Mean | SD | Mean | SD | |
1 | 3.575 | .594 | 3.750 | .494 |
2 | 3.600 | .496 | 3.800 | .405 |
3 | 3.950 | .221 | 4.00 | .000 |
4 | 3.650 | .483 | 3.600 | .744 |
5 | 3.800 | .405 | 3.900 | .304 |
6 | 3.625 | .490 | 3.850 | .362 |
7 | 2.875 | 1.399 | 3.100 | 1.277 |
8 | 3.425 | .813 | 3.450 | .815 |
9 | 3.225 | .832 | 3.425 | .549 |
10 | 3.525 | .554 | 3.650 | .483 |
11 | 3.625 | .490 | 3.800 | .405 |
12 | 3.450 | .783 | 3.725 | .506 |
13 | 3.850 | .362 | 3.825 | .385 |
14 | 3.225 | .698 | 3.475 | .640 |
15 | 3.550 | .783 | 3.700 | .464 |
16 | 2.325 | 1.118 | 2.650 | 1.075 |
17 | 3.575 | .549 | 3.650 | .483 |
18 | 3.150 | .622 | 3.175 | .636 |
19 | 2.900 | .632 | 3.150 | .580 |
20 | 2.800 | .687 | 2.975 | .577 |
21 | 3.475 | .640 | 3.500 | .599 |
22 | 3.050 | .783 | 3.150 | .893 |
23 | 3.175 | .903 | 3.300 | .791 |
24 | 3.625 | .586 | 3.875 | .335 |
25 | 3.275 | .784 | 3.525 | .679 |
26 | 2.900 | .841 | 3.125 | .723 |
27 | 3.425 | .675 | 3.600 | .545 |
28 | 3.675 | .526 | 3.750 | .439 |
29 | 3.275 | .599 | 3.425 | .594 |
30 | 2.650 | 1.167 | 3.775 | 6.318 |
31 | 2.800 | .758 | 3.125 | .686 |
Descriptive Statistics from frequency
analysis for Teacher Librarians Beliefs
Question | Mean | SD |
32 | 3.921 | .273 |
33 | 3.842 | .437 |
34 | 3.632 | .541 |
35 | 3.763 | .431 |
36 | 2.289 | 1.011 |
37 | 3.737 | .446 |
38 | 1.5 | 1.007 |
39 | 3.342 | .669 |
40 | 3.526 | .797 |
41 | 3.711 | .460 |
42 | 3.553 | .504 |
43 | 2.447 | 1.224 |
44 | 3.447 | .602 |
45 | 3.395 | .718 |
46 | 3.579 | .793 |
47 | 3.605 | .495 |
48 | 3.289 | 1.113 |
49 | 2.763 | 1.173 |
50 | 3.211 | .843 |
51 | 3.737 | .446 |
52 | 2.553 | 1.329 |
53 | 3.289 | .956 |
The Majority of TL’s believe that the following statements:
Descriptive Statistics from frequency
analysis for Principals Beliefs
Question | Mean | SD |
32 | 3.700 | .464 |
33 | 3.725 | .506 |
34 | 3.525 | .933 |
35 | 3.100 | 1.194 |
36 | 2.025 | .862 |
37 | 3.525 | .506 |
38 | 2.100 | 1.081 |
39 | 3.050 | 1.037 |
40 | 3.425 | .549 |
41 | 3.650 | .483 |
42 | 3.475 | .599 |
43 | 2.300 | .992 |
44 | 3.350 | .483 |
45 | 3.325 | .656 |
46 | 3.700 | .464 |
47 | 2.875 | 1.067 |
48 | 3.000 | 1.301 |
49 | 3.275 | .506 |
50 | 3.600 | .744 |
Principals differed to TLs in that:
T-Tests - Present vs Future Analysis
Teacher Librarians
Due to limited space only the questions
that yielded significant differences between time currently spent and time
perceived to be required in the future are presented. To be considered
significant a difference had to be significant at p =/< .01.
Question | Present | Present | Future | Future | P value |
Mean | SD | Mean | SD | ||
10 | 2.78 | 1.166 | 3.52 | .89 | .003 |
12 | 2.13 | 1.18 | 3.29 | 1.43 | .000 |
14 | 2.39 | 1.24 | 3.23 | .99 | .001 |
16 | 2.42 | 1.32 | 3.16 | 1.22 | .008 |
21 | 2.78 | 1.29 | 3.32 | .93 | .009 |
22 | 2.79 | 1.044 | 3.21 | 1.044 | .008 |
29 | 2.65 | 1.27 | 3.26 | .97 | .005 |
2 | 3.18 | 1.010 | 3.73 | .76 | .006 |
30 | 2.13 | 1.58 | 3.13 | 1.09 | .000 |
31 | 1.63 | 1.42 | 2.73 | 1.17 | .000 |
This analysis demonstrated that TL’s believe their principals should be spending more time in the future on the following tasks than they feel they currently do:
Question | Present | Present | Future | Future | P value |
Mean | SD | Mean | SD | ||
12 | 3.45 | .783 | 3.72 | .506 | .003 |
14 | 3.225 | .698 | 3.475 | .640 | .001 |
19 | 2.900 | .632 | 3.15 | .580 | .003 |
24 | 3.625 | .586 | 3.875 | .335 | .003 |
31 | 2.800 | .758 | 3.125 | .686 | .000 |
6 | 3.625 | .362 | 3.850 | .490 | .000 |
This analysis demonstrated that principals also believe they should be spending more time in the future on the following tasks than they feel they currently do:
Teacher Librarian vs Principal
Present and Future Questions and
Beliefs
All significant t-values were unequal
t-values due to the violation of the homogeneity of variance assumption
on these questions.
Question | Levenes F - value | Levenes p-value | T-value | df | p-value |
5 Present | 18.288 | .000 | -3.06 | 48.21 | .004 |
9 Present | 11.966 | .001 | -3.44 | 62.32 | .001 |
10 Present | 17.531 | .000 | -3.53 | 52.29 | .001 |
12 Present | 20.321 | .000 | -5.00 | 56.55 | .000 |
14 Present | 14.237 | .000 | -3.61 | 57.59 | .001 |
18 Present | 10.580 | .002 | -2.68 | 60.43 | .009 |
21 Present | 11.844 | .001 | -2.93 | 53.37 | .005 |
28 Present | 10.555 | .002 | -3.53 | 50.97 | .001 |
29 Present | 18.922 | .000 | -2.71 | 51.86 | .009 |
31 Present | 39.511 | .000 | -4.49 | 55.80 | .000 |
35 Belief | 9.531 | .003 | 3.29 | 49.44 | .002 |
47 Belief | 4.338 | .041 | 3.91 | 55.69 | .000 |
Question | TL Mean | TL SD | Principal Mean | Principal SD |
5 Present | 3.2632 | 1.005 | 3.8 | .405 |
9 Present | 2.3684 | 1.303 | 3.225 | .832 |
10 Present | 2.7895 | 1.166 | 3.5250 | .554 |
12 Present | 2.1316 | 1.436 | 3.45 | .783 |
14 Present | 2.3947 | 1.242 | 3.2250 | .698 |
18 Present | 2.6316 | 1.025 | 3.15 | .622 |
21 Present | 2.7895 | 1.298 | 3.475 | .64 |
28 Present | 2.9474 | 1.161 | 3.675 | .526 |
29 Present | 2.6579 | 1.279 | 3.275 | .599 |
31 Present | 1.6316 | 1.422 | 2.8 | .758 |
35 Belief | 3.7632 | .431 | 3.1 | 1.194 |
47 Belief | 3.6053 | .495 | 2.8750 | 1.067 |
Analysis indicates that Principals and TLs differ on how much time they think the Principal currently spends on the following tasks. TLs consistently felt that the Principal spent less time on the tasks than the Principals felt they do:
Other Variables
Teach Prior | Number Executive | Gender | |
Teacher Librarian - Mean | 2.2432 | .4444 | 1.000 |
Teacher Librarian - SD | 1.422 | 1.107 | .000 |
Principal - Mean | 4.1143 | 3.8286 | 1.5714 |
Principal - SD | .932 | 1.361 | .502 |
Levenes F- value | 7.041 | 5.995 | 1726.67 |
Levenes p - value | .010 | .017 | .000 |
t-value | -6.64 | -11.48 | -6.73 |
df | 62.48 | 65.49 | 34 |
p-value | .000 | .000 | .000 |
Teacher librarians and principals differed significantly on the number of years they have spent teaching prior to appointment to their current position, number of years in executive positions, and gender.
While the Teacher Librarians were more likely to have spent between 5-12 years teaching prior to their appointment as a TL, Principals were more likely to have spent between 15-19 years teaching prior to appointment as a principal.
Whilst Teacher Librarians were likely to have spent no time in executive positions, principals were likely to have spent between 13-19 years in such positions.
Whilst Teacher Librarians were 100% female (in this sample), principals were likely to be an almost equal blend of males and females.
Present and Future Overall
Present | Future | |
Teacher Librarian - Mean | 88.7105 | 104.2895 |
Teacher Librarian - SD | 22.394 | 22.008 |
Principal - Mean | 103.0250 | 108.8 |
Principal - SD | 8.775 | 10.047 |
Levenes F-value | 24.961 | 4.952 |
Levenes p-value | .000 | .029 |
t-value | -3.68 | -1.15 |
df | 47.62 | 51.2 |
p-value | .001 | .254 |
Principals and Teacher Librarians overall differed significantly on the amount of time they perceived the Principal to spend on tasks. Principals viewed themselves as spending more time on tasks than did the Teacher Librarians. However, in regard to time the Principal should spend on tasks in the future, Principals and Teacher Librarians were in line, there being no significant difference between the two groups.